Mood: incredulous
Now Playing: LAW & ORDER
Good grief, that was some bad writing. I just watched Elisabeth Rohm's swan song as ADA Serena Southerlyn, which wrapped up with a complete out-of-left-field non sequitur involving the character's homosexuality. The episode ends with Serena being fired by her boss, the district attorney (a solid Fred Dalton Thompson), because she's too passionate for prosecutorial work. After laying his cards on the table, explaining that she's an excellent attorney and that her passion makes her an advocate, which is the wrong temperament for putting bad guys in jail, he tells her, "You're fired." She pauses for a moment, and asks him, "Is this because I'm a lesbian?"
WTF?
Rohm has been on the show, stinking up the sets, for about four years now. There has never been any indication in any episode that she was gay, straight, bi, whatever. So they pick her final episode to do it. Well, in and of itself, that's okay. But do a show about that. Make her last case one involving gay rights and use Serena's orientation to make a point or serve the story. But to pelt us in literally the last fifteen seconds of her tenure with "Is this because I'm a lesbian?" (Thompson assures her, and us, that it isn't...and I believe him; who wouldn't believe Fred Thompson?) is just bad writing, an NBC-style "shock" ending that shocks only in its cheap theatricality.
Meanwhile, THE WEST WING might be getting better. What was once one of TV's best dramas sank to a recond low last season and didn't get off to a great start this year. However, the shift is now away from Martin Sheen's presidency and onto the upcoming presidential election, which has already introduced Jimmy Smits to the main cast. Smits is playing a personable Texas congressman whom Josh Lyman (Bradley Whitford) recruited to run for the presidency against Vice President "Bingo" Bob Russell (Gary Cole doing a great clueless guy) and oily ex-VP John Hoynes (Tim Matheson). Smits has already shaken things up, lightening the screen with major charisma and taking the focus of the show out of the White House and onto the campaign circuit, which creates new story ideas. Aside from Martin Sheen's arresting work as POTUS, the WEST WING cast was becoming too shrill for their own good, as the writers began penning out-of-character material for them and transforming the series from social drama to soap opera like executive producer John Wells' other series ER. I had pretty much given up on WEST WING last year, but Jimmy Smits and more future appearances by Alan Alda (whom Smits may be running against) have me interested again.
Did I use "whom" correctly? I hate that word.
Posted by Marty
at 4:17 PM CST